Mesh vs. Solid Pool Covers for Inground Pools: Which is Better?

When it comes to choosing pool covers for inground pools, one of the biggest decisions homeowners face is whether to go with a mesh or solid cover. Both serve the essential purpose of protecting your pool, but they each have unique advantages and drawbacks.

Mesh Pool Covers: Lightweight Protection

How Mesh Covers Work

Mesh pool covers are made of a tightly woven fabric that allows water and melted snow to pass through while blocking leaves, debris, and dirt. These covers are anchored securely around the pool and are known for their strength and durability.

Advantages of Mesh Pool Covers

  • Easy to Handle: Mesh covers are lightweight, making them easier to install, remove, and store.
     

  • Low Maintenance: Since rain and melted snow drain through the mesh, you don’t have to worry about water pooling on top.
     

  • Great for Winter Protection: Mesh are ideal for winterizing because they withstand snow and ice without collapsing.
     

  • No Pump Required: The draining design eliminates the need for a cover pump to remove standing water.
     

Disadvantages of Mesh Pool Covers

  • Allows Fine Debris: While large leaves and debris stay out, finer particles and dust may seep through.
     

  • Increased Algae Growth: Because sunlight can pass through, there’s a higher chance of algae growth during the off-season.
     

  • Chemical Imbalance: Rainwater passing through the mesh may dilute your pool’s chemical balance.
     

Solid Pool Covers: Maximum Barrier Protection

How Solid Covers Work

Solid pool covers for inground pools are made of vinyl or other non-porous materials. They create a complete barrier that prevents water, sunlight, and debris from entering the pool.

Advantages of Solid Pool Covers

  • Keeps Out Everything: Solid covers block all debris, rain, and sunlight, keeping the pool water cleaner.
     

  • Minimizes Algae Growth: With no sunlight penetration, algae growth is significantly reduced, especially during winter.
     

  • Better Chemical Retention: Solid covers help maintain water chemistry by preventing dilution from rain or snow.
     

  • Enhances Safety: High-quality solid covers can double as safety covers, providing a secure barrier over the pool.
     

Disadvantages of Solid Pool Covers

  • Heavier and Harder to Handle: Solid covers are bulkier, requiring more effort to install, remove, and store.
     

  • Needs a Cover Pump: Water will collect on the surface, requiring a pump to prevent sagging or damage.

Which Pool Cover Is Right for You?

Choosing between mesh and solid pool covers for inground pools depends on your specific needs:

Category

Mesh Cover

Solid Cover

Best For

Snowy climates, easy handling

Maximum cleanliness, algae prevention

Debris Protection

Good (large debris only)

Excellent (blocks all debris)

Algae Control

Moderate (allows sunlight)

Excellent (blocks sunlight)

Maintenance

Low (no water pump needed)

Moderate to High (needs water pump)

Weight/Handling

Lightweight

Heavy

Cost

Moderate

Higher

 

Conclusion:

Both mesh and solid pool covers for inground pools offer valuable protection, but the best choice comes down to your priorities:

  • Choose a mesh cover if you want a lighter, easier-to-manage option ideal for heavy snow regions.
     

  • Opt for a solid cover if keeping your pool crystal clear with minimal algae risk is your top concern.
     

No matter which you choose, investing in a quality pool cover is essential to protect your pool, save on maintenance, and extend the life of your investment.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15

Comments on “Mesh vs. Solid Pool Covers for Inground Pools: Which is Better?”

Leave a Reply

Gravatar